Listen In! Amanda to be featured on Voice America Radio

I will be featured on tomorrow's broadcast of The Kitchen Table Entrepreneur, a Voice America radio show hosted by Jackie Rogers.

The episode is titled "Mind Over Money" and I'll be on for the full hour. The Kitchen Table Entrepreneur features topics related to entrepreneurism, freelance employment, and business ownership. Most entrepreneurs are dreamers and risk-takers, and Jackie and I had a great time discussing the particular financial psychology of this group.

To listen to an archive of the broadcast, click here.

Paying for "Protection"

Did you know that the average overdraft amount is $17 but that the average overdraft penalty fee is $34? Does that seem right to you?

At this very moment there are several pieces of important banking legislation being crafted in Congress. Two in particular, H.R. 627 (the Credit Cardholders Bill of Rights) and H.R. 1456 (The Consumer Overdraft Protection Fair Practices Act) are lightening rods for consumer anger and frustration.

Americans for Fairness in Lending is collecting stories from consumers about their experiences with overdraft "protection" programs to pass along to Congress and The Federal Reserve as part of the official comment period on H.R. 1456.

IMPORTANT: The comments you submit will be part of the federal public record made available to the public online and in paper form. Your name and address may be included as part of your comment. Don't include your account numbers in your comment, or any other information you don't want made public.

How to be Successful in Conversations About Money

This Wednesday I will be taking part in a panel discussion titled "Yours, Mine, and Ours - Money and Relationships." The panel is presented by Barnard College's Young Alumnae Committee Office of Financial Fluency (don't you just love it?). I'll be presenting with my colleagues and friends, MP Dunleavey and Galia Gichon. Here's the text of the handout I'll be giving to attendees entitled "How to be Successful in Conversations about Money."

Start from a clear place.
It’s easier to communicate about money if you’ve already done your own homework, have your own goals, and have completed your own budget.

Be direct.
If you have a financial issue with another person, treat that issue (and the relationship) with respect by giving the subject your attention. Yes, it may feel uncomfortable to bring up a topic as sensitive as money. But it comes off as insincere to treat the subject casually, bring it up on your way out the door, or introduce it with, “Oh, by the way…”

Be concrete.
When trying to come to a consensus, make sure you’re both being concrete about goals, amounts, and time lines. This includes defining terms. For example, “You say it’s important to you that I be more responsible with money. What does it mean to be ‘responsible?’” “It means being able to pay for your lifestyle with cash. It means not having any credit card debt. [etc.]”

Just tell the truth.
You always have a right to your feelings and your point of view. Simply say, “I’m not comfortable with [spending $x on dinner right now].” Let the other person be responsible for how s/he chooses to respond.

Notice when it’s not about the money.
People use money in all kinds of interpersonal ways: to express love, to exert power and control, to punish, and to betray. Sometimes financial behavior becomes a way of saying something about what is happening in the relationship.

Money beliefs run deep.
Money connects with our most basic sense of security. Thus when someone feels financially threatened they may lash out (in an effort to self-protect) with an intensity that appears irrational to others. When you’re faced with a situation like this – someone is being overly aggressive, defensive, or resistant – rely heavily on Be Concrete and Just Tell the Truth.

Make consensus the goal.
Money is highly subjective and the other party has his/her own beliefs. Seek consensus instead of affirmation that your point of view is correct. Many friendships, relationships, and marriages have ended because each partner tries to make the other person agree that s/he is “right” about money.

Growing Pains

Yesterday the Dow closed at 7,100, and man, was I mad. I felt disappointed, angry, and resentful. Is it irrational to have these strong feelings about a non-human entity? You betcha. Is it a little crazy to feel like the market's "behavior" is out of line? Sure, but I would wager I'm not the only one who is re-evaluating her "relationship" with the market these days.

It feels terrible to lose money -- nothing odd about that -- but why was I taking it all so personally? The intensity of my feelings caught me off guard and I found myself pondering the relational nature of my experience. What role was I projecting onto the market, and what enactment was I engaging in? 

The closest parallel I could come up with was one of an adolescent going through the pains of maturation. I had come to expect the market to be a kind of benevolent parent. I followed the "rules" -- save your money, invest it, diversify your portfolio -- and then I expected the rest of it (the nurturing and growth of my money) to be "taken care of." 

Obviously the market is not a parent -- that's not the point I'm trying to make. And lots of people who were a lot more hands-on than me have lost even more money. 

But the growth pain that I'm going through is one of waking up and knowing that I have to be more responsible for myself. I have to do more homework. I have to make more informed decisions. I can't ever trust that my money is just going to be "taken care of."

I don't know what change this realization is going to make in my net worth. Maybe it won't change anything. But at least I will feel like more of a financial grown up living powerfully in the world, instead of a disappointed child. 

Are You Worth It?

MP Dunleavey has a great article in the NY Times today (subs. req.) about why debt seems to “stick” to some people but not others. Debt may be the result of your negative cash flow, she posits, but it may also be tied to the “emotional underbelly” of your spending.

T. Harv Ecker says something similar in Secrets of the Millionaire Mind. He wrote (and you’ll have to forgive me for paraphrasing, I don’t have the book here in front of me) that most people do not have the internal capacity to create and retain great wealth.

For Dunleavey and for Ecker the solution to one’s financial woes lies not in a better spreadsheet but in cultivating a better mindset.

I’ve definitely seen this phenomenon in my work. People tend to have very strong beliefs about themselves and their place in a money world. The problem is that these beliefs are usually unarticulated and live unchallenged in the person’s unconscious.

Unchallenged beliefs create patterns of behavior that resist every effort to change. For example, if you have an unconscious belief that having money will expose you to envy and resentment, you will always release the money in your life rather than risk being a target of antipathy. You will probably spend a lot of money on others and generally treat money with great disrespect. Any accumulation of cash will create a huge amount of anxiety, and as your bank balance rises so will your fear that other people are judging you.

The “secret” here (it’s actually not so very secret, but it is hard work) is to do some digging into your own financial psyche. Millionaire Mind is a good book, but I feel that books that only focus on wealth building are rather narrow in scope. Financial wellness should be about a lot more than just a string of fat assets. Dunleavey’s book, Money Can Buy Happiness, is a good one, so is The Money Mirror by Annette Lieberman and Vicki Lindner. For those in search of a more interpersonal approach is to start a Money Awareness Club per the folks at the Women’s Institute for Financial Education. Whatever method you choose, bringing your unconscious beliefs about money into awareness can be the most valuable experience of your life.

The Money Complex Just Got Less Complex

I haven’t written in awhile for a couple of reasons. Number one, work and my practice have been really busy (as you can imagine). Number two, our culture has been on a rollercoaster ride to match the dips and loops of the market. Each day seems to usher in a whole new socioeconomic “reality.” It astounds to me how quickly our society has pivoted to embrace values of frugality, simplicity, and human connection over consumer expression. As someone who works from a systems perspective, this is mind-bending stuff. It also feels slightly schizophrenic.

It puts me in mind of Arlene Modica Matthews’ book, Your Money, Your Self. In her book Ms. Matthews talks about the five-layer “Money Complex” which resides in each of us. Whenever we are poised to make a financial choice or action, our process gets filtered through each of these layers:

Layer 1: Intrapsychic Response – Feelings, reactions, the "little voice" of truth in your head.

Layer 2: Family Training Response –What you learned or saw in your family and how you interpreted that as right or wrong.

Layer 3: Social Training Response – What you believe is true about others, especially those you admire.

Layer 4: Technology Based Response – Is there a financial instrument (such as a credit card, HELOC, floating 0% balances) that will enable me to take – or avoid – this action?

Layer 5: Pack-think Response – The pressure you feel to do what everyone else is doing or not doing.

Certain layers are stronger or weaker than others depending on the individual and the situation.

In recent years financial stress has ticked quietly higher as our debt levels rose and certain middle-class givens started to stretch out of reach. The Intrapsychic Response Layer (“this feels terrible, something is wrong here”) was ignored while the Social Training Layer (“people like me have this, it's the normal thing”), Pack-think Layer (“I certainly don’t want to be the ONLY person who doesn’t have that”) and Technology Layer (“I can have it if I charge it and just pay the minimum”) ran the show.

This seismic cultural shift seems primarily driven by the about-face in financial technology – the loss of cheap, easy credit along with job insecurity and the end of perceived wealth from a stock boom and housing bubble. When the technology abruptly changed the culture did, too.

I didn’t have a name for it then, but I feel like the last two or three years of my practice might be summed up as Layer 4 Mania. People have been completely distracted by the myriad of financial instruments and scams. Our culture has mistaken the ability to buy something as the ability to afford something.

What we’re experiencing now is a hard, painful look in the mirror. The Intrapsychic Response Layer is screaming, and it’s finally being heard.

Amanda in the WSJ: Keeping Spending in Check

Different life transitions bring with them different financial challenges. For young people just entering the workforce post-college, the challenges include establishing a professional identity, developing a budget that balances their new expenses with their new income, and managing all of the stresses that come with any period of transition or change.

One of the ways that people often blow off emotional steam is with spending. How do you know when the spending -- particularly deficit spending -- is worth it? Figuring that out can be confusing when the new laptop or suit is something you "need" for your new professional life.

In my financial counseling practice I have an easy rule of thumb for figuring out when people are spending based on mood versus based on necessity. Was the purchase made on the spur of the moment or was it planned for? If it was done on the fly, there's good chance that anxiety, unease, or insecurity was responsible for the impulse to buy. Rationalization after the fact won't make up for that.

Shelly Banjo writes the Starting Out column in the Wall Street Journal and asked me how young professionals can Keep Spending in Check.